Trader Joe’s MAGNIFISAUCE (aka secret sauce!)

“A tangy sauce of secret proportions”

I’m guessing by phrasing it like that, Trader Joe’s can avoid MacDonald’s suing them but we still get it: “Magnifisauce” is like a certain “secret sauce” that comes on a Big Mac (and on In-And-Out Burgers too I’ve heard).

In reality these so called secret sauces are not secret recipes, they are more or less the classic deli dressing, Thousand Island dressing being some mayonnaise plus tomato (ketchup) and onion and pickle relish. So is Trader Joe’s Magnifisauce any good? It is. I like it.

I found Magnifisauce really tasty, then I’ve always liked Thousand Island and Russian dressings. I put it on as many things as possible to taste test it and found it was good on lots of different foods, it even works as a salad dressing.

First off, on a hamburgers of course. The sauce was really tasty on a burger, they make a great combo. You will also find it works well on many other things. For example I liked it with chicken. You can just drizzle some of this over slices of grilled chicken breast or any chicken and Voila, its looks like you made something fancy. This sauce compliments any kind of chicken quite well. You can even put it on some chicken you are grilling or broiling during the last minute of cooking as a glaze. Its good on plain old chicken nuggets. Shrimp. Its good for making deviled eggs. I just tried it on cottage cheese and I liked it too on it. Sandwiches? Of course. Its pretty much tasty on many things.

Just don’t forget its not shy with calories, though. Its has 100 calories per 2 tbls. so just be aware of that. Magnifisauce was 3.49. It was out of stock for a while. When I saw it back in the store recently (Aug ’23) I realized they raised the price. Its now $3.99 for a 9.5 oz bottle.

Want to make your own (not too) secret sauce? Make some Thousand Island dressing….